Top Grilling Errors That Ruin Your BBQ and How to Avoid Them

August 11, 2025

Every backyard barbecue enthusiast dreams of juicy meat, perfectly charred vegetables, and the unmistakable aroma of good food wafting through the air. But even seasoned grillers can fall victim to common grilling mistakes that turn a promising cookout into a frustrating experience. At Mathews BBQ Supply, we’ve helped thousands of customers upgrade their outdoor cooking game with expert guidance and premium tools. In this article, we’ll share the most frequent grilling errors, how to fix them, and which tools you need to make every BBQ a success.

Grilling Mistakes to Avoid When Using a Charcoal Grill

Charcoal grills offer more flavor and flexibility, but they also require more attention. A key mistake many make is using lighter fluid, which can alter the taste of your food and cause dangerous flare ups. Instead, use crumpled newspaper or a charcoal chimney to light your coals safely and evenly.

Look for gray ash on the coals before cooking—this signals they’re hot and ready. Placing food on too early can lead to inconsistent cooking temperatures and undercooked meat. Always preheat your grill and let the coals settle.

For precise temperature control, consider a grill like the Weber Performer Deluxe, which combines classic charcoal flavor with modern conveniences like a built-in timer and easy ash cleanup.

Tools Needed for Better Charcoal Grilling:

Charcoal chimney starter
Long-handled tongs
Heat-resistant gloves
Meat thermometer for checking internal temperatures

How Direct Heat and Indirect Heat Affect Your Meat

Not knowing when to use direct heat versus indirect heat is one of the most overlooked BBQ tips. Direct heat is best for steak, burgers, and vegetables like asparagus and corn. Indirect heat is ideal for larger cuts like smoked brisket, ribs, or pulled pork.

For example, when cooking a brisket, you’ll want to keep it on the cooler side of the grill and maintain low heat over several hours. Using a meat thermometer ensures you hit the right cooking temperature without overcooking the meat.

Christie Vanover of Girls Can Grill recommends layering flavor by seasoning the meat with salt, pepper, garlic powder, and brushing it with olive oil before placing it on the grill. This forms a crust that locks in moisture and adds a smoky finish.

Trimming Excess Fat and Prepping the Meat Properly

Trimming fat from meat may seem counterintuitive, but too much excess fat can cause flare ups and burnt edges. A sharp knife and a sturdy cutting board are essential for trimming and slicing. Remove silver skin and thick fat caps, especially on beef and pork, to allow seasonings to penetrate better.

Use a quality BBQ rub with spices like garlic, pepper, and brown sugar for a balanced flavor. For pulled pork or smoked brisket, Mathews BBQ Supply offers a range of premium rubs that enhance the natural taste of the meat.

Using the Right Cooking Temperature and Grill Grates

Many grilling mistakes result from incorrect heat levels. Cooking chicken or fish on high heat can dry it out, while using low heat for burgers or steak won’t give you the sear you need. Always preheat your grill and know your zones. Keep one side for high heat (direct) and the other for low (indirect).

Clean grill grates prevent sticking and help develop grill marks. A dirty grate can carry over old flavors or cause food to tear. Use a stainless steel brush or specialized grate scrubber before and after each cook.

Whether you’re using a gas grill like the Lion Premium L75000 or a woodfire grill such as the Bull Outlaw, both available at Mathews BBQ Supply, proper preheating and grate care make a big difference in the final result.

Don’t Forget to Let Meat Rest Before You Slice and Serve

One of the biggest mistakes people make is slicing meat right off the grill. Always let it rest for at least 10 minutes. This allows juices to redistribute, giving you more tender, delicious results whether you’re serving steak, chicken, or ribs.

Use a cutting board with a juice groove and a sharp knife to slice against the grain for maximum tenderness. Serve with a fresh salad, grilled vegetables, and your favorite BBQ sauce for a complete meal your guests will love.

Final Checklist for a Successful Backyard Barbecue:

Choose the right grill: charcoal, gas, or woodfire
Use a meat thermometer to avoid overcooking
Trim fat and silver skin before seasoning
Apply BBQ rubs and let the meat marinate
Preheat grill and clean grates thoroughly
Cook with the correct heat zone (direct vs indirect)
Let meat rest before slicing and serving

Great grilling comes down to preparation, temperature control, and the right tools. Whether you’re cooking pulled pork low and slow or searing a steak over high heat, following these steps will help you avoid common mistakes and deliver mouthwatering results every time.

Need help choosing your next grill or accessories? Contact us here.

Back to blog